When it's time to replace your roof in Buffalo or anywhere in Western New York, the first big decision is what material to use. The two most common choices are asphalt shingles and metal roofing. Both have real strengths and real trade-offs — here's the honest breakdown.
The honest answer is that there's no universal winner. The right material depends on your budget, how long you plan to own the home, your roof's pitch, your neighborhood's aesthetic, and how much you care about energy efficiency. After 10 years installing both in Western New York, we can break down the real-world differences.
Cost Comparison
Cost is usually the first question, and the answer surprises most homeowners.
| Factor | Asphalt Shingles | Metal Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| Installed Cost (avg home) | $8,000 – $14,000 | $18,000 – $35,000 |
| Lifespan in WNY | 20 – 30 years | 40 – 70 years |
| Installation Time | 2 – 4 days | 4 – 7 days |
| Maintenance | Low | Very Low |
| Snow Shedding | Good | Excellent |
| Ice Dam Risk | Moderate | Lower |
| Resale Value | Good | Very Good |
That's a 2–3x cost difference upfront. But metal roofing lasts 40 to 70 years, where asphalt shingles last 20 to 30 years in Western New York's climate. Over a 40-year ownership period, the per-year cost can actually favor metal. Over a 10-year ownership period, asphalt is the better financial choice.
Performance in Lake Effect Winters
Both materials perform well in Western New York winters when properly installed. Metal roofing sheds snow faster than asphalt, which can prevent ice dam formation. It also handles ice loads better because it doesn't absorb moisture the way aging shingles do.
Asphalt shingles handle snow load fine, but ice dams are a bigger risk because melting snow can back up under shingles where flashing or underlayment details are weak. With proper ice and water shield installed at the eaves (required by code in Buffalo), this risk is manageable.
Appearance and Resale Value
Architectural asphalt shingles come in dozens of color options that work with any Buffalo neighborhood. Designer shingles can mimic the look of slate or wood shake at a fraction of the cost. Metal roofing has come a long way — standing seam panels are sleek and modern, and stamped metal can look like tile or shake.
For resale in Buffalo and Rochester, both materials add value compared to old or damaged roofs. Metal sometimes commands a premium in higher-end markets, especially for homes built or renovated to a modern aesthetic. Asphalt is more universally accepted across all price points.
Lifespan and Warranties
Asphalt shingles in Western New York last 20 to 30 years with proper installation. GAF and Owens Corning architectural shingles come with 30 to 50 year warranties, but the practical lifespan in our climate is closer to 25 years for premium shingles and 20 years for standard architectural.
Metal roofing lasts 40 to 70 years. Manufacturer warranties on metal range from 40 to 50 years on the material, with paint warranties typically 30 to 35 years.
Installation Complexity
Asphalt installation in Buffalo is straightforward for qualified contractors. Metal installation is more specialized — standing seam requires custom panel forming and precision flashing details. If you're choosing metal, hire a contractor with documented metal roofing experience in Western New York. Metal installation mistakes are expensive to fix.
Free quotes for asphalt or metal roofing in Western NY. We install both — written estimate, no pressure.
Call (845) 746-1363Bottom Line: Which to Pick
For Most Buffalo Homeowners: Architectural Asphalt
For most Buffalo and Rochester homeowners, architectural asphalt shingles from GAF or Owens Corning offer the best combination of cost, performance, and aesthetic flexibility. Metal roofing makes sense for premium homes, owners planning to stay 20+ years, or buildings where the modern aesthetic of standing seam is preferred.
Choose asphalt if you're on a typical budget, selling within 10 years, or want maximum color and style flexibility
Choose metal if you're staying 20+ years, want a modern aesthetic, or have a steep pitch where shingle access is difficult
Either way — get a written estimate before committing. The difference in contractor quality matters more than the material
Frequently Asked Questions
Is metal roofing louder during rain in Buffalo?
Properly installed metal roofing over a solid deck with proper underlayment is not noticeably louder than asphalt. The barn-roof noise people remember is from metal installed directly over open framing.
Can I install metal roofing over my existing asphalt shingles?
Generally not recommended in Buffalo. Western New York code typically requires tear-off for any roof system change, and installing metal over asphalt creates ventilation problems.
Which material is better for solar panels in Western New York?
Standing seam metal is the easiest for solar installation because panels mount to the seams without roof penetrations. Asphalt requires roof-penetrating mounts, which is fine but adds points of potential leaks.
Free quotes for asphalt or metal roofing in Western NY. We install both and give you a clear written price.
Get a Free Estimate